home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT0199>
- <title>
- Jan. 28, 1991: Closing Ranks Behind The Yanks
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- Jan. 28, 1991 War In The Gulf
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- THE GULF WAR, Page 67
- THE EUROPEAN ALLIES
- Closing Ranks Behind the Yanks
- </hdr><body>
- <p>When the bombs started falling, the British, French and Italians
- were there; others with a stake in the gulf stayed to the side
- </p>
- <p>By MICHAEL S. SERRILL--Reported by Daniel Benjamin/ Bonn,
- Frank Melville/London and Frederick Ungeheuer/Paris
- </p>
- <p> As the countdown to conflict began, U.S. commanders surveyed
- the coalition's order of battle with some trepidation.
- Certainly British forces would be in at the start, but who else
- would line up to fight? French air and land units were in
- place, but at the 11th hour President Francois Mitterrand had
- launched what looked like a misguided missile: a compromise
- that offered Saddam Hussein his coveted Middle East peace
- conference. Italy, Spain, Germany and Greece backed Mitterrand.
- Had Baghdad not spurned the French proposal, the Arab alliance
- members might have wavered too and deserted the anti-Iraq
- coalition.
- </p>
- <p> Only when conflict was clearly unavoidable did the Europeans
- close rank. Even then their show of support was unequal--some
- contributing far more than others--and that was likely to
- lead to later recriminations, within both Europe and the NATO
- alliance. In Paris the nine-nation Western European Union
- defense grouping gave rhetorical support to military action
- last week, but while British, French and Italian warplanes ran
- the gauntlet of Iraqi antiaircraft fire, other European nations
- with a stake in gulf stability stayed on the sidelines. Germany
- was particularly conspicuous by its absence in the gulf, even
- if it had a constitutional excuse for nonparticipation. Warned
- British Foreign Secretary Douglas Hurd: "This will weigh on
- U.S.-European relations for some time."
- </p>
- <p> On the home front, Europe, like the U.S., braced for
- terrorism. Armored vehicles took up positions around London's
- Heathrow Airport as part of a dramatic increase in security in
- the capital. Throughout Europe, security forces carrying
- automatic weapons patrolled government offices, airports,
- airline offices, train stations and bus terminals. Key
- potential targets such as U.S. embassies, cultural missions and
- military bases were heavily guarded; schools catering to
- American students were closed. At the exclusive resort of
- Marbella on Spain's Costa del Sol, police and private guards
- swarmed around the summer palace of Saudi Arabia's King Fahd,
- transforming the oversize replica of the White House into an
- armed camp. "Marbella looks like a war zone," complained
- resident Nigel Bowden, a British writer.
- </p>
- <p> So did other parts of Europe, although, ironically, the
- belligerents were pacifists. While waiting for what many
- regarded as an inevitable Iraqi-instigated terror campaign in
- retaliation for the allied bombing in the gulf, security forces
- had their hands full keeping antiwar protesters in check. In
- the days before war began, and every day thereafter, tens of
- thousands of demonstrators, many of them students, took to the
- streets in Germany, France, Italy and other European countries.
- In Berlin they broke windows at the Grand Hotel and the French
- Cultural Center and hurled Molotov cocktails at a U.S. embassy
- annex. Even in Britain, where polls showed that the public
- supported gulf intervention by a 3-to-1 ratio, opponents of
- military action mounted antiwar demonstrations of an estimated
- 50,000 people.
- </p>
- <p> Beyond the rallies, however, there was never any doubt about
- Britain's resolve, even after Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher
- was replaced in mid-crisis by John Major. In a rare show of
- unity last week, the opposition Labour Party endorsed the
- Conservative Prime Minister's handling of the crisis and helped
- pass what was in effect a declaration of war by a House of
- Commons vote of 534 to 55. "We will not flinch in the battle
- against evil," Major told the British people. "Over the months,
- we have worked for peace. And hoped for peace. But we are
- prepared for war."
- </p>
- <p> In France there was never such clear resolution. Much to the
- annoyance of the U.S. and Britain, Mitterrand pursued his
- separate peace plan down to the wire. Eager to protect French
- interests in the Arab world, he also sought to appease a
- population nervous about military involvement and France's 4
- million-strong Arab immigrant community. His plan called for
- an Arab peacekeeping force to move into Kuwait in the wake of
- retreating Iraqi forces, which would be spared attack by
- coalition troops. It linked such a withdrawal to the convening
- of a U.N. Middle East conference to settle the Israeli-Arab
- conflict and the Palestinian problem. The majority of European
- Community members supported Paris' last-ditch effort, but it
- was opposed by the U.S. and Britain, which feared it would
- split the allies and let Saddam off the hook.
- </p>
- <p> In the end Baghdad brushed aside the French initiative, and
- less than 24 hours before hostilities began, the National
- Assembly voted overwhelmingly to support France's participation
- in armed intervention. Concluded Mitterrand: "Now arms will do
- the talking." It was an outcome Thatcher had foreseen as early
- as last August in the aftermath of the Iraqi invasion. Visiting
- George Bush in Aspen, Colo., the Iron Lady had predicted,
- "Mitterrand will give you trouble until the end, but when the
- ship sails, she [France] will be there."
- </p>
- <p> In Italy the decision was equally painstaking. It took an
- all-night emergency session, which ended 12 hours after the war
- started, for parliament to decide that its Tornado
- fighter-bombers deployed in the gulf since September should go
- into action against Iraq. Prime Minister Giulio Andreotti
- defended his decision to back the anti-Iraq coalition with
- vigor: "We cannot always demand that the Americans assume the
- entire burden of action." Accused of abetting a U.S. complot to
- safeguard cheap oil supplies, Andreotti shot back, "There was
- no oil to safekeep in Europe when the U.S. came here to fight
- and die as a decisive contribution in our liberation from the
- Nazi-Fascist dictatorship."
- </p>
- <p> With Britain, France and Italy aboard the war wagon, Germany
- was very much the odd man out. But with polls showing that 79%
- of the German people favored negotiations beyond the ultimate
- deadline, Chancellor Helmut Kohl concluded it was politically
- impossible for Bonn to go beyond supporting the coalition with
- cash, transportation aid and nonlethal supplies, such as
- poison-gas-detecting vehicles, to a total value of $2.2
- billion. Even its stationing of 18 aging fighters in Turkey in
- fulfillment of NATO obligations has been widely criticized at
- home. Upon hearing news of the attack on Iraq, the Chancellor
- declared himself "deeply distressed."
- </p>
- <p> The Bundestag eventually passed a resolution of support for
- the U.S. and its European neighbors. "They have a right to our
- solidarity, and we stand by them," said Kohl.
- </p>
- <p> The failure to unite in the face of the gulf crisis, even
- behind a single peace plan, dismayed advocates of a more
- assertive Europe and cast doubt on the Community's ambitions
- to achieve "political union" and a Euro-defense strategy.
- "Fundamental forces are tearing at the European Community,"
- said a senior U.S. official in Europe. "These strains will
- cause it to be taken less seriously as a united political force--by itself, by the U.S. and by others." Added Karl Kaiser,
- the director of Bonn's Foreign Policy Research Institute: "The
- E.C. is not available for out-of-Europe activities." What many
- Europeans, and particularly the Germans, do not understand,
- said Kaiser, is that "an international order under a United
- Nations mandate doesn't mean just resolutions. Under
- international law, force is legitimate."
- </p>
- <p> Were Europe, and in particular Germany, more assertive on
- the international stage, there would doubtless be protests from
- the very people hurling accusations of pusillanimity. But so
- far, the gulf crisis has shown that fortune favors the brave,
- and the laurels in the high-stakes enterprise of global
- leadership remain with the U.S. Seen just six months ago as a
- weak, declining power, Washington is attempting to pull a
- reluctant Europe into George Bush's new world order. The events
- in the gulf, says Pierre Dabezies, head of France's Foundation
- for National Defense Studies, reconfirm the U.S.'s new status
- "as the world's only remaining superpower--indeed, as its
- sole policeman."
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-